As Luthien pointed out the other day, I have been sadly deficient at updating. Partly this is due to Lent, partly to an unusually heavy school workload, and partly due to the joys of being a…well, you know.
For example, today I spent all day taking depositions in a case that is meandering — or lurching — toward trial. As are all such cases, it is immensely and unnecessarily complex. Still, you pursue every rabbit down its final hole, which provided some fine moments today.
To set the background, the wife has been living in Florida, taking the real estate exam, although not apparently with any intention of ever using it. Because she has an important appointment at a large city here in the state, she returns home for a few days. The husband (my client) then took her to the Large City, where they spent the night, went to the appointment and he then put her on a plane back to Florida. He returns home, and several weeks later writes her a letter saying he wants a divorce.
This did not sit well with wife, who several weeks after that returns to our little county, talks to a lawyer, and then goes to the courthouse, where she files a domestic violence complaint alleging that husband beat her up the day he drove her to Large City and, incidentally, that she has a desperate need of possession of the house for her residence, and asks that the sheriff remove said Bad Man immediately. Here we pick up the deposition:
Befuddled subdeacon: So, on March 29, your husband assaulted you?
Wife: yes.
BS: Later that day, did you drive to Large City — a trip of some 4 hours — with him?
W: yes.
BS: Did you then spend the night together in a hotel?
W: yes.
BS: Did he provide support for you the next day at the appointment?
W: oh, yes
BS: And then he dropped you off at the airport?
W: yes
BS: You did not report the assault to anyone during that time?
W: no
BS: You returned to North Carolina two months later?
W: yes
BS: And your husband did not know you were coming?
(Here insert long exchange concerning her inability to read husband’s mind, concluding with her admission that she never told him she was coming).
BS: Did you indicate on your domestic violence complaint that you needed to home to reside in?
W: I don’t know.
(BS shows W complaint. Repeats question.)
W: I don’t now what my intention was.
(BS scratches head): What do you mean? That your intention as you walked into the courthouse may have been different than it was when you filled out the paper, and different yet again when you left the courthouse?
W: yes
BS: Have you always lived your life so moment by moment?
W: Indeed I have.
BS: It is true, however, that before leaving Florida to come to North Carolina you paid the next month’s rent on your home in Florida?
W: well, yes.
BS: So how long were in the North Carolina home after the sheriff evicted your husband?
W: 2 weeks
BS: and you left in the company of a moving van?
W: well, yes.
BS: hmmmmm
Wife’s lawyer: ~mutters under her breath~
Tomorrow: endless hours of questioning about overseas bank accounts!
Yep, its Lent alright.